
The Ultimate Guide to Board Game Collecting: Tips and Best Practices

The Ultimate Guide to Board Game Collecting: Tips and Best Practices
Discover essential tips and best practices for successful board game collecting. Elevate your collection and enhance your gaming experience—read more!
The Allure of Board Game Collecting
Board game collecting is more than just a hobby; it’s a journey through the evolution of gameplay and design. This enriching experience allows collectors to appreciate the games, the memories, and the connections they foster across generations.
A growing trend
In recent years, this type of collecting has surged in popularity, capturing the attention of a diverse audience. The allure of these games lies in their ability to entertain while simultaneously connecting us to the past.
Board games provide a unique platform for bonding with family and friends, making them an enjoyable pastime for both kids and adults. There truly is a board game for everyone, catering to various tastes and preferences.
Nostalgia and history
Vintage board games hold a special place in the hearts of many enthusiasts, primarily due to the nostalgia they evoke along with their historical significance.
Remembering childhood favorites like Candyland and Life, and engaging in strategic battles with games like War in Europe, allows players to relive cherished memories while also appreciating the artistry of classic designs.
If you’re looking to begin your own board game collection, you’re in the right place! This blog explores all aspects of collecting, including essential tips for starting, maintaining, and even insuring your collection.
Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned collector, dive in now to discover the exciting world of board game collecting and find your next treasured piece!
Starting Your Board Game Collection
Embarking on a board game collection requires knowledge of different genres, eras, and publishers. This section is designed to guide beginners in identifying desirable titles, understanding various editions, and setting collecting goals.
Whether you’re interested in rare board games or looking for investment opportunities, having a solid foundation is key.
Building your knowledge
Having a solid knowledge base on different genres, eras, and publishers sets you up for success in your collecting journey.
A strong foundation helps you distinguish between authentic and counterfeit items and understand the design elements, pieces, and market value of your games.
Genres
Basic genres to explore include children and family-friendly games, hobby games, puzzle games, and role-playing games.
Additionally, familiarize yourself with various eras of board games: ancient games like the Royal Game of Ur, historical games from the Middle Ages or Roman Empire, and those from the Golden Age of Board Games from the 19th and 20th centuries.
Vintage board games from the 20th century, such as Monopoly or franchise games like Batman and Robin, also hold a significant place in collecting.
For a deeper understanding, check out our blogs “The Evolution of Board Games” and “The Rich History of Puzzles and Games.”
Titles and editions
In any collection niche, iconic titles and editions play a crucial role. When most people think of board games, classics like Monopoly, Clue, Candy Land, Scrabble, and Risk immediately come to mind.
Being familiar with these titles enhances your collecting strategy and helps you identify games that hold cultural significance and resale value.
Setting collecting goals
Setting clear goals is essential for guiding your board game collection strategy. Tailor your goals to fit your lifestyle: if you live in a small space, consider how much storage space and/or shelf space you have available.
Additionally, think about whether you’re more interested in high-value items or the thrill of the hunt itself.
Where to find your games
When it comes to sourcing games, there are plenty of opportunities both in person and online. Flea markets, antique stores, thrift stores, and gaming shops are fantastic places to find hidden gems.
Online platforms such as eBay can also be great for finding popular games, particularly those with high value. Just keep in mind that reputable auction sites may charge premium prices for sought-after items.

Evaluating and Appraising Your Board Games
Understanding the value of your collection is crucial, especially for insurance purposes. Accurately assessing the condition, rarity, and market demand of your board games can help you make informed decisions about safeguarding your investment, including knowing when to seek professional appraisals.
Importance of evaluation
Knowledge is key when building your collection. Classic games are particularly valuable due to their small numbers, leading to rarity and high demand.
To assess the physical condition of your vintage board game, start with the box. A valuable find typically features a picture on the outside that matches the inside. Pay attention to color quality, any signs of fading, edge wear, and creases.
Additionally, inspecting the contents will help gauge the game’s value. Having all the original pieces significantly increases the worth, especially if they are in excellent condition. A useful tip is to check the copyright year; games older than 1988 tend to be worth more money.
Seeking professional appraisal
If you have questions or need a professional evaluation, you may benefit ifromn seeking an appraiser. When choosing an appraiser, ensure they specialize in vintage board games and have a good reputation with positive reviews.
Keep in mind that some appraisers may charge professional fees, so factor that into your collecting budget. An expert in vintage board games will possess the necessary knowledge to assess the value of your collection accurately.
The connection to insurance
Understanding the value of your board game collection is essential if you plan to insure it. Knowing the worth will help you determine the type of protection needed.
Be aware that some insurance companies may require appraisals, so it’s important to read up on the requirements for insuring your collection.

Proper Storage and Display Techniques
Preserving your board games involves more than just shelving them. To maintain the integrity and longevity of your games, it’s essential to follow best practices for storage conditions, utilize effective display methods to prevent damage, and employ tools that help maintain functionality.
Storage solutions
Board games, especially older ones, can take up significant space. It’s crucial to ensure you have enough shelf space and to be selective when adding new games to your collection. Avoid cramming your games into a shelf, as this can lead to box damage.
Consider organizing your collection strategically; some prefer a categorization method. For instance, group tray-based games for kids on one shelf, cooperative games on another, and perhaps separate favorites or popular titles like Candy Land.
Organizing this way facilitates easy access and aids in keeping an inventory of your collection.
Preserving your board games
Furthermore, the environment where you store your board games plays a significant role in their condition and subsequent value.
Avoid locations with extreme temperature and humidity fluctuations, such as basements and attics. These areas can become too hot or cold, potentially damaging the games. Dampness in basements can lead to mold or fungus growth.
Ideally, store your collection in a climate-controlled space away from direct sunlight to uphold its quality.
Displaying your collection
Displaying your board game collection should be done thoughtfully.
If you’re using a display box, ensure it has UV-blocking capabilities to shield your games from harmful light. Regular dusting is vital for those games displayed outside of a case to prevent dirt accumulation.
Avoid placing games in areas that receive direct sunlight, as this can fade and damage pictures, artwork, and colors, as well as generate heat that could harm the pieces.
If your collection must be in a sunlit room, it is advisable to cover the windows with blinds or UV-blocking curtains or shades.
Connection to insurance
Understanding the link between storage and insurance is critical for any board game enthusiast. The way you store your collection may affect your insurance policy, just as how you display your games can influence their overall value.
It’s a wise move to consult with your insurance agent for advice or to gain clarity on any specific requirements or considerations regarding maintaining and protecting your valued collection.

Maintaining and Restoring Classic Board Games
Regular maintenance is essential for ensuring the longevity and playability of your board game collection. By implementing proper care, you can keep your games in good condition for years to come.
This includes understanding and using effective cleaning techniques, recognizing when restoration may be necessary, and knowing when to consult with experts for repairs.
Maintaining your collection
Once you have arranged for proper storage and display of your board games, maintenance becomes a critical next step. Regular dusting, checking, and inspecting each game will help ensure that they remain in prime condition.
Additionally, if you dedicate some gaming time, it’s important to keep track of all game components. Always check for essential items such as dice, cards, and tokens to confirm they are accounted for, as missing pieces can significantly decrease a game’s value.
Considerations for lost pieces
If a piece goes missing from your game, it can be tempting to seek out a replacement. However, keep in mind that many components, especially for vintage or classic games, could be rare and not original to the set.
Before hastily replacing a lost piece, consider the potential impact on the game’s overall value and authenticity. It’s advisable to weigh the importance of not playing against the desire to play.
Restoration practices
Restoration practices can occasionally be required to maintain the condition of classic board games. However, many collectors prefer to keep their games in their “as is” state, particularly older ones, because this often retains their historical value.
If you decide that restoration is necessary, consulting an expert can ensure that any repairs are done correctly and responsibly, preserving the integrity of the game.

Insuring Your Board Game Collection
Protecting your investment with appropriate insurance is vital, especially when it comes to your vintage board game collection. This collection might hold significant emotional, historical, and financial value.
Insuring your board games ensures that you will be adequately compensated for your losses in the event of unexpected incidents like property damage, fire, or theft.
Homeowners vs. collectibles insurance
Many people assume that their homeowners or renters’ insurance will cover their collections. While this can be true, it’s important to note that such policies often only cover the cash value of items rather than their full market value.
Additionally, homeowners’ insurance might limit coverage for personal belongings to a percentage of the home’s total value, and it may not cover damages from natural disasters such as hurricanes or earthquakes.
In contrast, an insurance policy dedicated to collectibles provides more comprehensive coverage, including protection against fire, theft, loss, and accidental damage.
The need for comprehensive coverage
Given the importance and worth of your vintage board game collection, investing in a specialized collectibles insurance policy is worth considering. This type of insurance typically offers broader protection specifically tailored for valuable items.
If you’re interested in exploring the possibilities of collectibles insurance, check out our website, collectinsure.com, for more details!
One important step to consider when insuring your board game collection is maintaining proper documentation. Doing so ensures that you receive fair compensation in the event of a claim and will be discussed in greater detail in the following section.

Documenting Your Collection for Insurance
Accurate records are essential for supporting insurance claims and appraisals of your board game collection. Maintaining an up-to-date inventory, complete with photographs and detailed descriptions, can significantly ease the insurance process.
The importance of accurate records
In the event of a claim or if an appraisal is needed, having thorough documentation can be a lifesaver. Cataloging your collection as it grows will benefit you in the long run, preventing the panic of scrambling to compile information when it’s urgently needed.
Documenting your collection during a crisis is stressful. So be kind to your future self and keep records of your collection!
Planning for the future
Documenting serves insurance purposes and plays a crucial role if you plan to leave it to family or friends. It’s important to consult an estate attorney in these cases to ensure everything is handled correctly.
Additionally, if you decide to sell your collection, comprehensive documentation can enhance its value and help prospective buyers understand its worth.
How to document your collection
When it comes to documenting your collection, a combination of physical and digital records works best.
For physical documentation, keep all receipts, relevant documents, game manuals, Certificates of Authenticity (COAs), and photographs organized in an archival-quality binder. Store this binder or a file in a safe place to protect it from damage.
On the digital side, maintain a spreadsheet to track your collection, including categories like the name of the game, date of purchase, date of release, purchase location, price, estimated market value, and any special details such as autographs, provenance, missing pieces, or additional accessories.
Protecting your records
It’s also advisable to scan your physical documents and digitize them in case of loss due to theft, fire, or floods. Always back up your spreadsheet and consider uploading both the scanned documents and spreadsheet to cloud-based storage for added security. This way, you can safeguard your valuable information and ensure easy access whenever you need it.

Navigating Inherited Board Game Collections
Inheriting a collection can be overwhelming, especially when it comes to board games that hold both sentimental and historical value. This section offers guidance on how to assess, preserve, and decide the future of inherited board games, whether you choose to keep, sell, or insure them.
Inherited a board game collection?
Congratulations on your new collection! It’s an exciting opportunity to have pieces of history right at your fingertips, but it’s understandable to feel overwhelmed, especially if it’s a sizable collection. No need to worry; we’ve got you covered.
The process of elimination
The first step is the process of elimination. Consider the storage in your house and the time and cost of maintaining the collection. Ask yourself why you want to keep certain games and what holds personal, emotional, or financial value for you.
For example, would you prefer to preserve the nostalgia associated with a vintage Candy Land or Life board game? Assess whether some games are in excellent condition while others are not.
If you decide to keep specific games, ensure you have adequate storage space in your house and consider whether insurance coverage is necessary, especially for valuable items.
Organizing your collection
If your inherited collection lacks organized documentation, take the initiative to create one. This will prove beneficial when seeking insurance, contemplating future sales, or continuing the tradition of passing the collection down to others.
Selling your collection
Meanwhile, if you decide that selling the games is the best option, understanding their value becomes critical. If your loved one maintained detailed files and records, you’re in a good position for a successful sale.
However, if such documentation is missing, conduct research to determine the games’ production dates and associated historical significance. Recognizing rarity and current demand will also help gauge their worth.
Consulting an appraiser
In case you find the research daunting or time-consuming, enlisting the help of a reputable appraiser specializing in board games could be a worthwhile investment, as they can provide a professional assessment of your collection. Just keep in mind that you may incur appraisal fees.
Insuring your collection
On the other hand, if you decide to keep the collection, insuring it is a smart decision, particularly given the risks of maintaining aging collectibles that might appreciate in value over time.
Work with an insurance company that specializes in collectibles, and consult your insurance agent for advice tailored to your needs.
For further assistance, consider visiting our website, collectinsure.com, where you can speak with a collectibles insurance expert today!

Engaging with the Board Game Collecting Community
Connecting with fellow collectors enhances knowledge and enjoyment of the hobby. Engaging with a community of enthusiasts allows individuals to share insights, trade games, and celebrate their passion for board games.
Whether through forums, clubs, or events, the camaraderie of collectors can significantly enrich one’s experience of board games.
The resurgence of board games
In the past few years, there has been a resurgence in the interest in board games, encompassing both new games and beloved classics. This revival has contributed to a vibrant board game community, where there truly is something for everyone.
Embracing online communities
Online options present an excellent alternative for those who seek flexibility or prefer to engage with a broader audience.
Platforms such as forums, online clubs, social media groups, and virtual meet-ups make it easy to connect with national and international communities of board game enthusiasts. These online resources offer a wealth of knowledge, from tips and strategies to recommendations for discovering hidden gems in the gaming world.
The thrill of in-person collecting
On the other hand, if you cherish face-to-face interactions, the world of in-person collecting offers endless fun and possibilities.
Attending conventions, joining local clubs, visiting gaming stores, or participating in game nights provides an invaluable social experience. These gatherings create opportunities to share tips, trade games, and make new friends who share the same passion for board games, adding a unique dimension to the collecting journey.

The Future of Board Game Collecting
The gaming industry is evolving, transforming the landscape of collecting.
New trends and the resurgence of classic games attract both nostalgic fans and newcomers. Digital platforms enhance access to rare board games and foster community connections, while also sparking interest in board game investing.
This blend of traditional collecting and modern technology is reshaping engagement with board games today.
Sources
https://toplayishuman.com/2019/01/30/twenty-essential-board-games-for-a-public-collectio
https://medium.com/@Back2Boardgames/my-minimalist-board-game-collection-2ac62bd44651
https://amyrogershays.com/2024/08/09/5-games-to-start-a-board-game-collection
https://www.austinwomansclub.com/20-most-valuable-vintage-board-games-worth-money
https://norerolls.co.uk/2024/06/18/on-the-satisfaction-and-dangers-of-collecting-board-games/
https://dailyworkerplacement.com/2017/12/11/the-six-stages-of-board-game-collecting/
https://www.meeplemountain.com/articles/why-you-should-limit-your-board-game-collection/
https://boardgamegeek.com/blog/10203/blogpost/167313/looking-after-a-board-game-collection
About Collectibles Insurance Services
Collectibles Insurance Services has been protecting collections since 1966 and all coverage is provided by a carrier with a group rating of “A” (Excellent) by AM Best, the leading rating agency for the insurance industry.
Comprehensive coverage includes, but is not limited to: accidental breakage, burglary, fire, flood, loss in the mail, theft, natural disasters, and other causes of loss unless specifically excluded from the policy. Deductibles start at $0 for collector policies and we provide coverage for the market value of your collection for losses in excess of $50.
Additionally the protection extends At home and away, and we don't require collection itemization and serial number nor extensive paperwork and red tape.