Coverage for your childhood treasures.

From model airplanes to action
figures, deductibles starting at $0 for toys coverage.

Playfully simple insurance

Toys

Collectibles Insurance for Toys

Perhaps it has something to do with the nostalgia, but toy collections are among the most popular things to collect. Whether it’s a Breyer horse, a prized action figure, a Barbie doll, or a limited-edition board game, we’ve got you covered! Collectibles Insurance Services can help offer protection to keep your favorite vintage and antique toys secure.

Comprehensive Toy Insurance

  • Accidental Breakage
  • ​Burglary
  • Fire
  • Flood (except in Zones A & V)
  • Loss in the Mail
  • Natural Disasters
  • Theft
  • Other causes of loss, unless specifically excluded from the policy (see exclusions)

Coverage for Your Toy Collection at Home and Away

  • Travel – Transit coverage protects collectible property that is temporarily away from the scheduled location, subject to the policy sublimit.​
  • Exhibitions – If you’re at a scheduled exhibition, show, or display, coverage is provided for your prized toys up to the policy limit – including travel and shipping to and from the event.
  • Storage Facilities – For an additional premium, we offer optional insurance coverage for toys kept in a public storage facility.

More Affordable Rates

We offer insurance policies with offer affordable coverage compared to the average insurance policy! Typically, the cost for a policy we offer is less than it would cost to schedule the same items under a homeowners insurance policy.

Less Paperwork and Red Tape

Unlike the average homeowners policy, we do not require a schedule or appraisal for most items; however, you are responsible for maintaining your own inventory of your toy collection for insurance purposes (in the event of loss). The only exceptions are individual items or sets valued over $25,000 apiece, which would have to be scheduled items.

We’re Proven and Trusted

We offer policies that are proven and trusted! We have been insuring collectibles like yours since 1966. And all coverage is provided by a carrier with a group rating of “A” (Excellent) by AM Best – the leading rating agency for the insurance industry.

Deductibles starting at $0

Deductibles start at $0 for collector policies. We provide coverage for the market value of your toys for losses in excess of $50. All dealer policies have a $200 deductible.

Insurance that grows with your collectibles

Collections tend to grow, so your policy can be adjusted to include any newly acquired items.

Inflation coverage

You may select “Automatic Monthly Increase” as optional extra coverage to be added to your policy for new acquisitions and appreciation of your existing collectibles. Selecting this coverage will apply a monthly automatic coverage increase of 1% in coverage, up to a maximum of $1 million.

We provide coverage for dealers, too

If you want to protect your dealer inventory and your clients’ private collections, for which you are responsible, we also offer special Dealers Insurance.

Superior customer service

Our company was started by collectors, so it’s only natural that we pay attention to your interests and needs. And that our customer service would always be geared to the collector’s point of view.

Prompt and personal claim service

As experienced specialists in toy collections, our adjusters understand the value and importance of your collection. That’s why, should you have a claim, they make every effort to make sure it is settled as quickly and completely as possible.

CIS Company Brochure

Want to learn more about the services we offer? Check out our collector brochure and our dealer brochure.

Related Services

We don’t just help cover your toy collection! We help provide coverage for collectibles of all kinds. The list of what we cover is longer than our list of what we don’t.

Get A Quote

Getting a quote is fast and easy! If you’re interested in insuring your toy collection, be sure to get a quote today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, we offer comprehensive and broad coverage for your toy collection! We have experience insuring collectors of all kinds who appreciate the scope and special coverage.

CIS is a company founded by collectors, so we understand that your toy collection is often more of an emotional investment than a financial one and that these collectibles are worth far more to its owner than money alone. As experts in collectibles insurance, we have been protecting valued collectible toys and more since 1966—offering not just coverage, but the kind of peace of mind that a standard homeowners policy simply cannot provide. Here are just a few reasons why you should choose CIS to provide insurance for your valuable collectibles:

  • Proven and Trusted – Protecting toy collectors and more since 1966, all coverage is provided by a carrier with a group rating of “A” (Excellent) by AM Best, the leading rating agency for the insurance industry.
  • Coverage at Home and Away – We provide insurance at any scheduled location in the United States. But, that’s not all. We provide transit coverage, which protects collectible property that is temporarily away from the scheduled location (subject to policy sublimit). If you’re at a scheduled exhibition, show, or display, coverage is provided for your collectibles up to the policy limit—including travel and shipping to and from the event. We also provide optional coverage for collectibles kept in a public storage facility (up to $100,000).
  • Comprehensive Coverage  Coverage includes, but is not limited to, accidental breakage, burglary, fire, flood (except in zones A & V), loss in the mail, theft, natural disasters, and other causes of loss unless specifically excluded from the insurance policy.
  • More Affordable Rates – Typically, you will pay less than it would cost to schedule the same items under your homeowners policy. Deductibles start at $0 for collector policies, and we provide coverage for the market value of your toys for losses in excess of $50.
  • Less Paperwork and Red Tape – Unlike homeowners, a schedule or appraisal is not required for most items; however, you are responsible for maintaining your own inventory for insurance purposes (in the event of loss). Individual items or sets whose insured value is set at $25,000 or more must be scheduled.
  • It’s Fast and Easy – Get a quote online or call our expert CIS team at 888-837-9537 (8:30 am – 5:00 pm (EST), Monday – Friday).

Our company was created by an avid stamp collector who realized that ordinary homeowners coverage simply couldn’t provide the coverage his rare treasures demanded. For everyday, easily replaced personal property, homeowners is all most people need. But for prized possessions you may have spent a lifetime collecting, it doesn’t go nearly far enough. That’s why we offer a group of benefits that the less specialized insurance carrier doesn’t often provide. For example:

  • Homeowners coverage is typically based on the actual cash value of your collectibles—not their current market value or full collector value.
  • Homeowners can limit coverage of all the contents in your home to a percentage of your home’s total value (usually between 50% and 70%).
  • It may not cover losses caused by floods, hurricanes, or earthquakes.
  • Homeowners may have limited or no coverage for valuables like silver, guns, stamps, and other collectible items.
  • You may be required to appraise and schedule all items individually. And new items must be reported and scheduled within 30 to 90 days of acquisition.

Like most collectors, we’re specialists. Providing collectible insurance is all we do. So we’re able to passionately focus on servicing the needs of collectors like you. Generally, if you can collect it, we can cover it. (The list of what we provide coverage for is a lot longer than what we don’t.) Some of the most popular categories we cover include comics; guns, knives, and accessories; sports cards and memorabilia; stamps; and toys.

The following are excluded: Government seizure or destruction of property; war and nuclear hazards; gradual deterioration such as fading, creasing or denting; nesting, infestation or discharge or release of waste products or secretions by insects, rodents or other animals; dampness or dryness of atmosphere; changes in or extremes of temperature other than fire; fraudulent, dishonest or criminal acts; voluntary parting with covered property; loss or damage while being worked on by you or others working on your behalf; and mysterious disappearance. This is not a complete list of exclusions and exclusions can vary by policy.

From Franklin Mint to Barbie, to American Girl, we’ve got your precious collection covered. No matter your doll of choice, we’re here to give you peace of mind so that you can focus on what you do best – adding to your collection.

If you’re looking for protection for that limited-edition Star Wars LEGO® set, Collectibles Insurance Services is here for you! We have helped insure collections of all sizes since 1996 (and stamps for nearly 50 years), so we know how much you value your collection. That’s why we provide equally valuable features in our insurance offering.

If you’re seeking protection for that prized Hot Wheels Sweet Sixteen set, you’ve come to the right place. We have helped insured collections of all sizes since 1996 (and stamps for nearly 50 years), so we have the experience and knowledge to help provide you with excellent coverage.

If you’re seeking protection for that your prized limited-edition Barbie doll, we’ve got your back! We have helped insured collections of all sizes since 1996 (and stamps for nearly 50 years), so we know how much you value your collection. That’s why we provide equally valuable features in our coverage.